Reps. Justin Amash And Thomas Massie Clash Over Military Transgender Funding

in News by
   

Rep. Justin Amash (R-MI) and Rep. Thomas Massie (R-KY) have been thick as thieves throughout their Congressional tenure, but find themselves more frequently at odds during the Trump era. Their most recent disagreement stems from a failed amendment to the 2018 NDAA that would have banned the funding of transgendered surgeries by the military.

“Still in disbelief that Congress passed a defense authorization (NDAA) earlier today that funds sex changes for members of the military, as well as $43 billion for our 17th year of the war in Afghanistan. I voted no,” Massie wrote in a Facebook post after the NDAA passed but the amendment to block military transgender funding failed.

After Amash had previously referred to headlines indicating that he had voted to authorize military transgender funding as “fake news,” he was asked about Massie’s remarks. Amash responded that he felt his long-time colleague was missing the mark in his assessment.

“He is wrong here,” Amash wrote on Facebook in response to Massie. “The NDAA does not fund sex changes; it doesn’t say anything about transgender persons.”

Amash’s carefully worded response is very telling, as he did not specifically refer to the amendment in question. The amendment, proposed by Vicky Hartzler (R-MO), was rejected by Amash, moderate Republican legislators, and every Democratic House member. It read as follows:

“Funds available to the Department of Defense may not be used to provide medical treatment (other than mental health treatment) related to gender transition to a person entitled to medical care under chapter 55 of title 10, United States Code.”

“Military service is a privilege — not a right — predicated on the singular goal of fighting and winning our nation’s wars. All decisions on personnel and funding should be made with this in mind. High entry and retention standards are required because failure in the job costs lives. Last year’s transgender decision is costly in dollars and short on common sense,” Hartzler said.

Close allies throughout the Obama era, Massie and Amash have been far less congruent under President Trump’s leadership. Amash has led the charge with Democrats and moderate Republicans to investigate Russian collusion accusations, while Massie has sided with conservative lawmakers dismissing the allegations as a partisan witch-hunt. Amash also voted affirmatively on the American Health Care Act, while Massie stood strong against it, even when faced with intense pressure from the White House.

Enjoyed the article? Make a contribution to support our work via Patreon!

Shane has been an activist for liberty-related causes for over 10 years. He is the Media Relations Director of the Republican Liberty Caucus of Michigan, State Director of the Michigan Tenth Amendment Center, and County Coordinator for Michigan Campaign for Liberty.

  • There is no military application apparent for gender reassignment in the military. Thus, the government should not be paying for it. Military members earn pay and can choose to pay for it themselves if so desired, and is not a detriment to their volunteered service.

  • I have to say…I am very disappointed with Issa and Amash!
    I thought these two were above doing something like this!

    It’s time “we The People” do our duty and “Drain The Swamp” of these RiNO’s in the next GOP Primary! Replacing these anti-American Republicans with Constitutional Conservatives/Federalists!!!

    • Issa barely won his seat and it’s turning Democratic Party leaning.

    • Nessa Silva, doesn’t this “(other than mental health treatment) related to gender transition to a person entitled to medical care” under the military health system” create a loophole for lawyers to manipulate in allowing the mis-appropriation of taxpayer money for a procedure like gender reassignment?

  • Why have all the comments that included Amash’s statement been deleted?

    • What did he say?

    • Because LC is a beta-Trump-cuck group

    • LC doesn’t delete comments we disagree with. The only comments we would even consider deleting would be promotion of illegal activities or violence.

    • Amash’s own statement was included in the article.

    • From Justin Amash.

      “That headline is fake news. Sec. Mattis and the White House oppose the amendment. They are working on a policy and want an opportunity to craft it. The underlying bill says nothing about transgender individuals, and voting no on the amendment expends no money. I think it’s reasonable to support the Trump administration’s position under the circumstances. The highest ranking member of the Armed Forces in the House, Rep. Jack Bergman, also voted no.”

      -Justin Amash-

      • Cytotoxic

        So IOW the rightnet is mostly hot and bothered over a whole lot of nothing. Must be a day ending in ‘y’.

    • Not completely. But the comment I made here with the full Amash statement was deleted.

  • One is a fiscal conservative, the other panders to progressives.

  • I came up with a middle ground where we ban the procedure for enlisted members and limit it to people who left after ten years or more of honorable service. The more stuff we subsidize via health insurance the higher the costs will be for all.

  • The plug should be pulled on the funding for this. If someone wants to ruin there body by changing from man to woman or vise versa then that person should be responsible for every last cent!

  • Forget the trans issue, Amash voted for the NDAA and that crap of a healthcare bill. What is going through his head???

    • Cytotoxic

      The House version of the AHCA, while not repeal, is the best we’re probably going to get. It has an escape clause that lets states opt out of Ocare more or less, and therefore it is logical to support it. Massie holding out does not make much sense.

    • He wrote a very long article about what exactly was going through his head.

  • http://i.imgur.com/k0U5y2v.png

    amash defends his vote based on the trans issue? what about that “war” funding?

  • What is he thinking

  • it should be banned it is one of the most stupid sickening disgusting things ever….

  • This is an elective surgery. We have Vets doing without and this is ludicrous….no tax money should be spent on this!

  • Glenda Brown

  • Cytotoxic

    The real scandal here isn’t the piddling money spent on trans issues it’s the ongoing aimless pointless war in Afghanistan. On this point Massie is totally right! Wrap it up!

  • Amash has been slowly selling out over the past few years, it started with his vote for Paul Ryan, voted against Kate’s law, now this. Amash is wrong, not Massie.

  • What happened to Amash? Turned statist?

  • tz1

    Amash has become a left-libertarian more worried about LGBTQ, racism, sexism, than actual freedom. The libertarian movement is splitting into the Jeffrey Tucker virtue signalling wing and the more traditional wing, but the latter is joining the alt-right.

  • Charles Byrd

    Looks like Amash is starting to go cosmo.

  • Look at his reasoning on Twitter. Mathis told people to vote against it so he could develop the policy.

  • I was just about to tag you. Why don’t you go primary him?

  • Smash has become a clown.

  • Response from Justin when I asked him,

    ” Rudy, that headline is fake news. Sec. Mattis and the White House oppose the amendment. They are working on a policy and want an opportunity to craft it. The underlying bill says nothing about transgender individuals, and voting no on the amendment expends no money. I think it’s reasonable to support the Trump administration’s position under the circumstances. The highest ranking member of the Armed Forces in the House, Rep. Jack Bergman, also voted no.”

  • Amash explains his vote. And he holds a reasonable and defensible position as always : https://m.facebook.com/story.php?story_fbid=1480080775364657&id=173604349345646

Latest from News

Go to Top

Thanks for visiting our site! Stay in touch with us by subscribing to our newsletter. You will receive all of our latest updates, articles, endorsements, interviews, and videos direct to your inbox. 

Send this to friend